Stickney, Benjamin D.; Fitzpatrick, Jody
In 1966, James Coleman's massive American
schooling survey concluded that family background was principally
associated with the existing inequities in cognitive achievement.
Coleman's conclusion about schooling's minimal influence on academic
performance violated an educational consciousness viewing school as the
"great equalizer." Two decades after the Coleman Report, this paper
explores schools' compensation for class-related inequalities by
reviewing the effectiveness of federal egalitarian educational programs
and by describing one state study of the relationship between various
environmental variables and pupil achievement. Part I addresses three
assumptions underlying the rationale for compensatory education in the
early 1960s: (1) the total environment profoundly influences measured
intelligence and school achievement; (2) schools are part of the total
environment; and (3) improved schooling for disadvantaged children could
compensate for inadequacies in measured intelligence and scholastic
achievement caused by environmental deficiencies. After reviewing
research since 1966, the paper focuses on the issue of sustaining
effects. Apparently, a "fade out" of early gains is a continuing
problem. Part II describes a Colorado survey for third-, sixth-, ninth-,
and eleventh-grade levels using regression analysis techniques. Results
suggest that school-related variables do influence achievement, but
their impact is restricted to the lower grades--perhaps due to a
strengthening of peer and community mores during adolescence. Similar to
Coleman, the current survey finds family variables more related to
achievement than are school variables. Included are 80 references. (MLH)
schooling survey concluded that family background was principally
associated with the existing inequities in cognitive achievement.
Coleman's conclusion about schooling's minimal influence on academic
performance violated an educational consciousness viewing school as the
"great equalizer." Two decades after the Coleman Report, this paper
explores schools' compensation for class-related inequalities by
reviewing the effectiveness of federal egalitarian educational programs
and by describing one state study of the relationship between various
environmental variables and pupil achievement. Part I addresses three
assumptions underlying the rationale for compensatory education in the
early 1960s: (1) the total environment profoundly influences measured
intelligence and school achievement; (2) schools are part of the total
environment; and (3) improved schooling for disadvantaged children could
compensate for inadequacies in measured intelligence and scholastic
achievement caused by environmental deficiencies. After reviewing
research since 1966, the paper focuses on the issue of sustaining
effects. Apparently, a "fade out" of early gains is a continuing
problem. Part II describes a Colorado survey for third-, sixth-, ninth-,
and eleventh-grade levels using regression analysis techniques. Results
suggest that school-related variables do influence achievement, but
their impact is restricted to the lower grades--perhaps due to a
strengthening of peer and community mores during adolescence. Similar to
Coleman, the current survey finds family variables more related to
achievement than are school variables. Included are 80 references. (MLH)